I blogged earlier today about the $500K salary cap. It turns out that this cap is only really applicable to firms that take future TARP funds, not those who already have. Does this make the cap more palatable? After all, the only firms that are likely to request future funding are those who are already in dire straits. I think this is the wrong way to look at the cap. The form of the cap seems to me to be hugely anticompetetive--early TARP recipients got no-strings-attached loans, whereas future TARP recipients will have huge strings attached to any funding they receive. The federal government appears to have engaged in an attempt to not only pick winners (which they are notoriously bad at), but to help out their "chosen ones" by forcing their competitors enter into a Faustian bargain should they want access to the same same government funds.
Showing posts with label U.S. Economy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label U.S. Economy. Show all posts
Wednesday, February 4, 2009
Wednesday, December 17, 2008
New York Tax Hike
The New York Government is attempting to introduce nearly 100 new taxes to make up for a looming budget defecit. I have two points to make. First, most obviously, perhaps the answer is not to increase taxes but rather to reduct spending. But that ideological point aside, I think the more important point is that these taxes are likely to flop and not provide the amount of revenue expected, and in a worst case could potentially lead to an absolute reduction in revenues. When over half the state's population live extremely close to a state border (New York City accounts for nearly 40% of the state's population), these taxes could potentially induce consumers to drive a few extra miles (to New Jersey or Connecticut, say) to avoid paying taxes.
Monday, July 7, 2008
Anti-Speculation Bill: Stabilizing or Destabilizing.
The US Government's new Anti-oil-speculation bill sure sounds like it will help stabilize oil prices. In actuality, however, this law is more likely to destabilize prices rather than stabilize them, and could ultimately have some very unfortunate unintended consequences.
Prices are not simply the amount of money one needs to part with in order to obtain some good or service. They are also an extremely simple, yet powerful, method of storing and conveying information. Buyers and sellers who have high quality information about the supply or demand of a particular commodity, in particular why that price may be too high or too low, can exploit this information for a profit. In the process of exploiting this information, the information they hold about that commodity becomes embodied in the market price. For example, if I am one of very people who know about an untapped oil reserve, I have high quality information that the price of oil is likely to fall. This means I could make a profit by selling oil futures.
What the new anti-speculation bill means is that people with good information will no longer be able to exploit this information to earn a profit by "speculating" on the oil market. As a result, market prices will no longer fully reflect all available information, and individuals and corporations will be more likely to make bad decisions when those decisions depend on energy prices.
Presumably the government is concerned about speculators pushing the price of oil up further, implying that the bill will lead to market prices being too low. So the likely results of the anti-speculation bill would include consumers buying less fuel efficient cars than they otherwise would, using more oil-based energy than they otherwise would, and other decisions implying an overuse of petroleum based energy sources. Ultimately, this bill will exacerbate the energy problem confronting the US economy because consumers will not face the true costs of the decisions they are making.
Prices are not simply the amount of money one needs to part with in order to obtain some good or service. They are also an extremely simple, yet powerful, method of storing and conveying information. Buyers and sellers who have high quality information about the supply or demand of a particular commodity, in particular why that price may be too high or too low, can exploit this information for a profit. In the process of exploiting this information, the information they hold about that commodity becomes embodied in the market price. For example, if I am one of very people who know about an untapped oil reserve, I have high quality information that the price of oil is likely to fall. This means I could make a profit by selling oil futures.
What the new anti-speculation bill means is that people with good information will no longer be able to exploit this information to earn a profit by "speculating" on the oil market. As a result, market prices will no longer fully reflect all available information, and individuals and corporations will be more likely to make bad decisions when those decisions depend on energy prices.
Presumably the government is concerned about speculators pushing the price of oil up further, implying that the bill will lead to market prices being too low. So the likely results of the anti-speculation bill would include consumers buying less fuel efficient cars than they otherwise would, using more oil-based energy than they otherwise would, and other decisions implying an overuse of petroleum based energy sources. Ultimately, this bill will exacerbate the energy problem confronting the US economy because consumers will not face the true costs of the decisions they are making.
Tuesday, January 29, 2008
Bush's Stimulus Package
So, the venerable G W Bush has decided to launch a stimulus package to fix the U.S. economy. Anything to take the focus off of the debacle that is Iraq, I suppose. But seriously, the fact that the stimulus package is news (as opposed to the fact that Bush thinks it will work) is really an indictment of just how little the public understands of economics. First things first, the notion of economic stimulus through Keynesian mechanisms is asinine. Here's an analogy. You owe your bookie $1,000, payable today. You have that $1,000 in your pocket. Your bookie calls you and says he won't come pick that money up today, but instead will pick it up in a week. Do you spend that $1,000 now and work your butt off over the next week to get another $1,000 to pay him off, or just hold onto the original $1,000 until the bookie comes to pick it up? Bush thinks you'll choose door number 1. Most economists think you'll take door number 2. They may call it "Ricardian equivalence" or the "permanent income hypothesis," but really it simply boils down to the fact that normal people aren't going to go nuts and drop twenty large on random goods when you push the collection date of their (tax) debt into the future.
However, let's put all the foregoing to the side for a moment. Let's say you do think this sort of economic stimulus will work. You really should be irate at Bush for waiting until now to do it! If Bush just has to wave his magic wand to make the economy perform better, why is he waiting until now? Why not do it when the economy is going along just fine, so that it will perform even better? Surely if you can turn a (say) 0.5% growth rate into a 1.5% growth rate, the same economic policy will turn a 2% growth rate into a 3% growth rate. In other words, if the government can do better than markets when markets are down, why can't they do it when markets are up? Also, in a completely unrelated question, why is government size generally inversely correlated with government growth?
Oh, hey, I do know the answer to this. Markets rarely perform poorly. And when they do, we really shouldn't call the government to fix it, because the poor performance is likely attributable to the government messing something up.
However, let's put all the foregoing to the side for a moment. Let's say you do think this sort of economic stimulus will work. You really should be irate at Bush for waiting until now to do it! If Bush just has to wave his magic wand to make the economy perform better, why is he waiting until now? Why not do it when the economy is going along just fine, so that it will perform even better? Surely if you can turn a (say) 0.5% growth rate into a 1.5% growth rate, the same economic policy will turn a 2% growth rate into a 3% growth rate. In other words, if the government can do better than markets when markets are down, why can't they do it when markets are up? Also, in a completely unrelated question, why is government size generally inversely correlated with government growth?
Oh, hey, I do know the answer to this. Markets rarely perform poorly. And when they do, we really shouldn't call the government to fix it, because the poor performance is likely attributable to the government messing something up.
Labels:
Bush,
economic policy,
recession,
stimulus,
U.S. Economy
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)